More lighting love

I am totally into this light at Design within Reach. Except to me, a floor lamp that is more than $100 is not within reach for most people - especially given the current economic times. And though I usually HATE WalMart, I was super surprised to see this number which is essentially the same design concept at about 1/4 the cost.

Compare them: Can you tell which one is the budget buster and which one is a super saver?